The story is everywhere.
You cannot get away from it.
It is unfathomable. It is sickening.
As a Catholic, which I don't say out loud much these days, I cannot wrap my head around the recently released grand jury report. You've seen the news stories so I won't go into any details. Many of us are struggling. I know this because I've spoken with fellow Catholics, family and friends, and we just don't know where to go from here.
I am not a practicing Roman Catholic. I was baptized in the Byzantine Rite, which falls under the Catholic umbrella and puts us under the leadership of the Pope, but we have our own bishops and governing hierarchy. Our services are more Orthodox than Roman oriented. Since setting out on my own, I have been practicing the Byzantine faith steadily for about 20 years.
When I was little, my family would attend Roman Catholic services occasionally if we could not make it to our usual 11 a.m. Divine Liturgy. I never attended Roman services enough to become particularly close with any of the priests until college.
During my freshman year at the University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown, I often attended Sunday mass. It was comforting for my mom to know I was going to church while away at school and, even though there was not a Byzantine service in our non-denominational chapel, there was a Roman Catholic one each Sunday. My attendance each week led me to come to know the priest who celebrated mass, Fr. Joe, and I eventually joined the Newman Group, a club for young Catholics like myself.
This group was very important to me because I was living away from home for the first time and I needed to be a part of something familiar. I had a lot of questions and concerns and our meetings provided an opportunity to pray, discuss different topics and get a fresh perspective from a priest who felt like one of us.
He was down to earth, and easy to talk to. He was different from any priest I had encountered up to that point. He made me feel like a peer instead of a kid. Fr. Joe was someone I could go to and talk and I really needed that freshman year as my parents were going through a tough time back home. I needed security and the Newman Group provided that.
We even went on a weekend retreat to a local bed and breakfast. We made our own meals, ate tons of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups covered in whipped cream and had rap sessions at night. It was nice to talk candidly with a priest and be taken seriously. I felt like he answered our questions without the fire and brimstone answers we were used to getting. It made me feel good to know things weren't as black and white as they had always seemed growing up. I felt like I grew in my faith that year and that God seemed more approachable than ever before.
Three years ago, I saw Fr. Joe's picture in an online news story about a priest who had molested children at a homeless center in Honduras. I was in shock. I wanted to be sure it was my Fr. Joe and once I confirmed the last name and his affiliation with UPJ, there was no denying it was him.
Apparently, Joe would help raise money in the Altoona-Johnstown diocese to help support orphaned children in Central and South America and then make a couple of trips during the year to deliver money and supplies. His trips, unfortunately, were more than missions of charity. He is currently serving a 16 year, 8 month prison sentence and will face lifetime probation upon release.
I am not alone. Many people have stories about special priests who led a secret life. I have asked myself how could Joe have done this? How could this person, who helped me during a rough time in my life, also masquerade as a child predator - this man of God? I also wonder about the weekend retreats our Newman Group took back in college. Was someone in our group molested? Is he or she walking around with emotional scars that won't ever heal?
It is a hard time to be Catholic. It is a hard time to have faith but now is when we need it most. I am writing this not because I have the answers or any new insight on this horrible story. I am writing this because personally, I, need to find a way to move forward.
A few years ago, Fr. Joe was just a priest I knew who was sick and had a serious problem. Now, he is one of hundreds across the state. My feelings are at the surface again, but I can't push them down this time. Where does the Catholic Church go from here? God help us.